Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (2024)

Published: September 25th, 2017

Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (1)

“Rumble, young man, Rumble!”

— Muhammad Ali

It’s strange to think that the modern iteration of the Dodge Challenger has now been in production for twice as long as its inspiration. One has to either admire or despair at the way that Dodge has managed to keep this one-trick pony on the lips of the automotive universe, simply by throwing more and more horsepower at it. FCA knows their audience — who cares that the platform is more than a decade old? Just make it faster! Would any of us be surprised to see a 1,000 horsepower Challenger revealed next year? Hell, why not just make it so powerful that it rips itself in half?

But, as with most performance-oriented cars, the real cheddar comes from the volume models. The Deep South is rotten with V6-powered Challys, and the original 3.5-liter, 250-horsepower models are the star of many a Buy Here Pay Here Lot. And while the 2015 and newer Pentastars, which are masterfully mated with the ZF 8HP automatic, can be enjoyable to drive, let’s be the realest here, k? Nobody lusts after a Challenger with too few cylinders. It’s the HEMI rumble that you want. And the Dodge Challenger R/T delivers it, albeit in 5.7-liter form, and it does it at a price that’s right in line with the average new car price in these United States of America.

Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (2)

I selected the Challenger R/T from the rental row at Miami International Airport (Pro tip: if you want the best rental car selection, fly in on a Sunday — NOBODY flies in on Sunday), resplendent in what some might call Rental White, and what Dodge would call White Knuckle, but on a Challenger, it can only be called Vanishing Point White. From the outside, it’s a handsome steed. 20-inch painted rims come standard, and the limited badging — a little R/T here, a little HEMI there — is a tasteful hint that there’s something more than just the Pentastar under the hood.

When placed side-by-side with the Ecoboost Mustang convertible rentals, as it was by my good friends at National, one is quickly reminded of just how big the Chally is. The modern Mustang is already far too large and bloated, but the Challenger outsizes it. This isn’t a bad thing, especially if your pony car schedule includes more cruising than tracking. If you plan to make any use at all of the back seat, the Challenger’s extra bloat will be worth it, and the additional trunk space comes in handy, as well.

A car this immense requires immense presence. Not to worry. To my delight, merely starting the Challenger in the MIA garage caused several surrounding car alarms to go haywire. This is, of course, by design — the rumble of the 5.7-liter V8 is distinctive, easily differentiated from the sixer, and nearly as loud inside the cabin as out.

Oh, no. I mentioned the cabin. Well, might as well get this sad tale out of the way.

It sucks. I mean, it suuuuuuhhhhhhhhhcks. It’s a depressing, sad, defeating place to spend your time. This infotainment screen belongs in a Journey, not in a R/T Challenger. It’s not even purposefully minimalistic, like the stereo system found in the 2012/2013 Boss 302. It’s just cheap —if you want the real uConnect screen, it’s gonna cost you another grand. And it doesn’t get better elsewhere inside the Chally’s interior — materials are visibly bargain-oriented. In fact, there’s only one teensy little redeeming factor contained within.

Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (4)

Okay, this is an admittedly terrible picture, but hopefully you can make out that little “SPORT” button on the console. That button, my friends, is the key to unlocking the aural masterpiece that is the Dodge Challenger R/T. One little push, and bam, the exhaust becomes a cacophonous symphony, thanks to higher shift points from the 8-speed.

But whereas the ZF transmission and the Pentastar seem to be a match made in heaven, the 5.7 and the ZF are more like a match made on Tinder — they never actually talk to each other. The transmission always wants to upshift before your ears think it should. Just when you’re starting to make a nice little ruckus, nope, sorry, we’re shifting now! For true aural enjoyment, you’ll want to take care of the shifting yourself. For hot 0-to-60 runs, you’ll want to follow the expertise of the gentleman in this thrilling video below:

Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (5)

The square 245 all-season tire setup does nothing to inspire performance driving in the hearts of men. The rears will break loose under any significant throttle, and the fronts wash out rather easily. They do, however, make excellent squealy sounds from a standing start, and when driving around the mean streets of Miami, the combination of the roaring 5.7 and the smoke and keening from the tires at red lights will make you an instant target of Dade County’s finest.

Unfortunately, that’s the only time anybody will take note of you in the Challenger R/T. The sheer ubiquitous nature of the Challenger, virtually visually unchanged for a decade, means that a car that might have gotten you some looks back in the day is now the social equivalent of an Altima. Nobody will mistake the R/T for a Hellcat Widebody, either in looks or sound.

All that being said, there’s an excellent case to be made for the base model of the Challenger R/T as a daily driver. With all the incentives currently offered, a Chally just like my rental can be had for $31,430, and that’s before a single bit of negotiation takes place. Add a real infotainment system and some summer tires, and you’re still at just over $33k — or, in other words, exactly the average US new car transaction price. For that, you get a car that will run a mid 13 in the 1/4, sounds like the business, and gets, well, horrible gas mileage. I averaged about 19 mpg. However, it can actually be used for four adults, and will allow you to put more than one suitcase in the trunk.

Rental Review: 2017 Dodge Challenger R/T - Cheap, Fast, and Dirty, but Maybe Not Cheap or Fast Enough (2024)

FAQs

At what mileage do Dodge Challengers start having problems? ›

If you follow proper service schedule and regular maintenance, you can get your Challenger running for 200,000 up to 400,000 miles.

What was the best year for the RT Challenger? ›

In general, you'll want to stick with the newer Challengers after 2015 since they're modern and have higher predicted reliability ratings. Challengers from 2008-2012 reportedly had numerous reliability woes, including power steering and electrical system issues.

Is the 2017 Challenger RT reliable? ›

How Reliable Is the 2017 Dodge Challenger? The 2017 Challenger has an above-average predicted reliability rating of four out of five from J.D. Power.

Are RT challengers fast? ›

The eight-speed automatic gearbox changes cogs quickly. The driver is able to sustain speeds over 124 miles per hour (200 kilometers per hour) for a while in this clip. Stay tuned until the end to see the Challenger hit a speedometer-indicated 153 mph (246 kph).

What are the disadvantages of the Dodge Challenger? ›

Poor Fuel Efficiency

The Dodge Challenger is notorious for its high fuel consumption. With a large engine and a heavy body, the Challenger's fuel efficiency is significantly lower than many other vehicles in its class. This can lead to frequent visits to the gas station and increased costs over time.

How many miles can a Dodge Challenger RT go on a full tank? ›

What is the Driving Range of the Dodge Challenger? The 2021 Dodge Challenger has a 425-mile driving range, on the base SXT model. Looking into the fuel mileage of the standard Challenger trim, drivers will get 19 miles per gallon in the city, 30mpg cruising on the highway, and 23 miles per gallon combined.

Do Challenger RT hold their value? ›

A Dodge Challenger will depreciate 29% after 5 years and have a 5 year resale value of $37,790.

What year is the fastest Challenger? ›

The 2023 Dodge Challenger SRT Demon 170 pulls the highest G-force acceleration of any production car at 2.004 gs, hits the 60-ft. mark in 1.24 seconds, and reaches 60 mph in 1.66 seconds on its way to a quarter-mile elapsed time (ET) of 8.91 seconds at 151.17 mph.

Is a Challenger RT faster than a gt? ›

The Ford Mustang GT goes from 0 to 60 mph in 4.2 seconds, while the Dodge Challenger R/T completes the 0-60 sprint in 4.8 seconds. However, the Challenger R/T Scat Pack fights back with a 0-60 mph time of 4.2 seconds, and the SRT Hellcat makes the same sprint in 3.7 seconds.

What is a 2017 Dodge Challenger RT worth? ›

Used 2017 Dodge Challenger Pricing
Original MSRPKBB Fair Purchase Price (nat'l average)
R/T Coupe 2D$35,785$21,023
T/A Coupe 2D$38,490$21,386
T/A Plus Coupe 2D$41,290$27,170
R/T Plus Coupe 2D$41,590$22,263
10 more rows

Are Challengers cheap to fix? ›

Each service varies in cost depending on your Challenger's model as well as the place of repair. Overall, the costs can accumulate to over $8,000 to $10,500 or more for 10 years. Stick around to learn more about Dodge Challenger maintenance costs.

Are Dodge Challengers high maintenance? ›

Dodge Challengers require repairs approximately 0.2 times yearly (about once every five years) compared to other mid-sized cars, which average 0.4 yearly repairs (every 2-3 years). This means you'll need repairs half as often as a typical mid-sized vehicle and routine maintenance can reduce this number further.

Are challengers faster than Camaros? ›

Top Speed: Even with their base engines, the Challenger and Camaro are lightning-fast. The Camaro reaches 165 mph, while the Challenger can go up to 11 mph faster!

How fast is a 5.7 Hemi Challenger RT? ›

You'll also be able to get up to a stunning 155 mph 2023 Dodge Challenger R/T top speed. While this is not a speed suitable for the highway, we highly encourage you to go to the track and strut your stuff with all the power that Dodge offers you.

What is the quickest Dodge Challenger? ›

A Dodge special-edition vehicle like none other, the 2023 Dodge Challenger SRT Demon 170 is the quickest vehicle ever produced in the brand's 100-plus-year history.

How reliable are Dodge Challengers? ›

Dodge Challengers require repairs approximately 0.2 times yearly (about once every five years) compared to other mid-sized cars, which average 0.4 yearly repairs (every 2-3 years). This means you'll need repairs half as often as a typical mid-sized vehicle and routine maintenance can reduce this number further.

What kind of mileage does a Dodge Challenger get? ›

2022 Dodge Challenger MPG By Trim Level

Here's a quick overview of the each model's fuel economy: Challenger SXT: 19 city/ 30 highway MPG. Challenger GT: 19 city/ 30 highway MPG. Challenger R/T: 15 city/ 23 highway MPG.

How many miles is too much for a Dodge Charger? ›

However, the general feedback regarding the Charger's lifespan seems to be between 150,000 to 250,000 miles. This seems to be an accurate estimate based on discussion boards like the Charger Forums, where people shared how easily the Charger cleared the 100k-mile mark.

Are the new Dodge Challengers reliable? ›

Quality and Reliability 85.0/100

The 2023 Dodge Challenger has a predicted reliability score of 85 out of 100.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 6471

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.